Trying to Decide Between Windermere and Dr. Phillips?
Blog Author: Jen Durben | The Funk Collection, Brokered by eXP Realty
If you are looking for your next move in Orlando, whether relocating from out of state or across town, narrowing down the areas of the Orlando metro is typically one of the first decisions. And, if the decision is between Windermere and Dr. Phillips and you're not sure how they compare, this guide will help differentiate the two communities.
At a high level, these two areas feel like siblings. Both are located in Southwest Orlando and border each other (Windermere to the West, in the 34786 zip code, and Dr. Phillips to the East, in the 32836 & 32819 zip codes). Both offer well-established residential communities with a mix of amenities, including gated and guard-gated options, lake access, golf access, and a range of home styles.
- Windermere is known for its lake town-feel, with a defined small downtown and excellent proximity to Disney.
- Dr. Phillips offers a connected lifestyle with easy access to popular Restaurant Row, Universal, downtown, and major roadways.
So, what makes residents choose one area over another? For many people, the decision becomes clearer when focusing on how each area supports everyday routines and lifestyle as well as the individual neighborhood feel.
But what really sets these two apart?
Windermere vs. Dr. Phillips At A Glance
Windermere
- On-the-water lifestyle opportunities along the Butler Chain of Lakes
- Defined downtown with local events and a community feel
- Close to Disney, especially from the southern side
- Residential setting that feels separate from the busier parts of Orlando
- Community options with newer homes
Dr. Phillips
- Known for Restaurant Row and the multitude of shopping options and services nearby
- Convenient access to Universal, Disney, I-4, and downtown
- Established communities with pockets of newer construction communities
- Lifestyle built around accessibility and everyday convenience
- Located amongst the Butler Chain of Lakes and Sand Lake Chain
>> Living In Windermere
>> Living in Dr. Phillips
Is Windermere, Florida A good place to live?
Windermere is a strong option for those looking for a lake-centered lifestyle, a small-town feel, and excellent "back door" proximity to Disney.
The Butler Chain of Lakes plays a big role in that. Neighborhoods and roads are often shaped around water, which creates a sense of space and separation without being far from everything.
Common reasons people consider Windermere:
- Access to the Butler Chain of Lakes
- A defined downtown with community events
- Residential areas that feel separate from commercial corridors
- Proximity to Disney without a tourist-heavy environment
- Selection of Newer Communities with a variety of gated, lake access, and golf access homes
In some neighborhoods, especially on the southern side, nightly fireworks from Disney are visible.
>> Windermere Communities with Disney Fireworks Views
For those exploring housing options, many communities also offer gated or guard-gated entrances.
>> Search Windermere gated communities
Does Windermere have a downtown?
Yes, and it’s one of the defining characteristics of the area. Windermere has a true town center that creates a sense of place.
What you’ll find:
- Brick-lined streets and walkable areas
- A historic town hall, a statement icon in the middle of town
- Weekly farmers markets
- Monthly food truck nights
- Local shops and a brewery
- Community Events like the Annual Windermere Among the Lakes 5K/10K & Windermere Pet Fest
Is Dr. Phillips, Florida A good place to live?
Dr. Phillips is a strong option for those who want to live close to Orlando's popular dining, entertainment, and to both Universal and Disney.
Dr. Phillips offers a different kind of everyday experience. It is still very much residential, with established communities and a wide range of housing options, but it is layered with accessibility to the rest of the Orlando metro.
Common reasons people consider Dr. Phillips:
- Central location with access to major roadways and downtown
- A wide range of popular dining on Restaurant Row and everyday conveniences
- Established communities with long-term presence
- Close proximity to Universal, Disney, and SeaWorld
- Access to world-class golf, including Arnold Palmer's Bay Hill Golf Club
- Communities along the east side of the Butler Chain of Lakes and amongst the Sand Lake Chain
Like Windermere, select southern Dr. Phillips neighborhoods have views of fireworks from Disney and, on special occasions, from Universal.
>> Dr. Phillips Communities with Fireworks Views
For those exploring housing options, many communities also offer gated or guard-gated entrances.
>> Search Dr. Phillips gated communities
What is Restaurant Row in Dr. Phillips?
While Dr. Phillips technically doesn't have a downtown in the traditional sense, Restaurant Row is one of its most recognized features.
Located along Sand Lake Road, it offers one of the highest concentrations of dining options in Central Florida.
What makes it stand out:
- A wide range of cuisines in one area
- Options for both casual dining and higher-end experiences
- A social environment that is active throughout the week
- In addition to restaurants, popular shopping and grocery options like Whole Foods and Trader Joe's are here
In addition, areas like O-Town to the south continue to expand dining and retail options, adding to the overall convenience of the area.
Is Dr. Phillips close to Universal and Disney?
Dr. Phillips offers quick access to the Orlando's world-class attractions, centrally located between the major parks.
From most parts of Dr. Phillips:
- Universal Studios, Islands of Adventure, and Epic Universe are in Dr. Phillips backyard
- SeaWorld & Discovery Cove are also within a short drive
- Disney Parks and Disney Springs are easily accessible from the south
For those wanting access to both the major park areas, this location tends to stand out.
Which is more expensive: Windermere or Dr. Phillips?
Short answer: Both areas offer a range of pricing depending on location, community, features, and home type.
In both Windermere and Dr. Phillips:
- Pricing varies based on proximity, features, and community
- Options range from lower-maintenance homes to larger estate properties
In general:
- Condos & Townhomes can start in the low $300s, while lakefront homes in Windermere can command higher price points, especially in luxury communities like Isleworth, where homes have sold upwards of $11.5 million in the past year.
- Condos here can start in the mid $200s, while golf-course or highly centralized locations in Dr. Phillips can also command premium pricing in communities like Golden Oak, Disney's luxury neighborhood, where homes have sold up to $14 million in the past year.
Should you choose Windermere or Dr. Phillips?
The most unsatisfying answer is that the best choice depends on the individual. It's really more of a question of what is most important to you. Because of the similarities, it will likely come down to the neighborhood and homes themselves.
Windermere may be for you if:
- A lake-centered lifestyle is important
- A defined town feel adds value
- Being near Disney without feeling surrounded by it is appealing
Dr. Phillips may be for you if:
- Convenience and accessibility are priorities
- Dining and social options are part of everyday routine
- Access to both Universal and Disney is important
A local perspective from Jeff and Renee Funk
After more than 25 years living and working in Southwest Orlando, Jeff and Renee Funk understand the area's draw and why so many people choose to live here.
From raising a family in Windermere to helping buyers and sellers navigate both Windermere and Dr. Phillips, one thing becomes clear over time. The right choice is less about comparing the two and more about understanding how each customer's lifestyle needs are unique. As local Disney fans they also have the inside scoop on the top communities to live near the parks.
Some are naturally drawn to the lake-centered feel and the town's character of Windermere. Others prefer the accessibility and energy that come with living in Dr. Phillips. Both offer strong options. The difference lies in how each one aligns with the pace and priorities that matter most.
That’s where local perspective helps. Not to push one direction, but to bring clarity to what may not be obvious at first glance.
Ready to connect with the team to uncover if Windermere or Dr. Phillips is for you? Schedule a call with Jeff today.
Posted by Jen Durben on
Leave A Comment