Windermere: 7 Odd but True Facts Behind the Luxury Zip Code

What are Surprising Facts About Windermere, FL?

Blog Author: Renee Funk | Co-Founder, Speaker, Trainer

Windermere, Florida, has deep roots in Central Florida, with a quaint downtown and a setting among the lakes that feel almost untouched by time. Established decades before the area’s major growth, the town has maintained its small-town vibe while also collecting its share of odd but true facts.

1. The Infamous Dirt Roads of Windermere

Why does Windermere still have dirt roads downtown? Originally, when the town of Windermere was being built, paving downtown sand streets was not a priority. Funding fell short, so the town's sandy dirt roads became part of its charm. More than 100 years later, the sand roads are still part of Windermere’s identity. Even with the maintenance they require, many residents continue to support keeping them unpaved to preserve the town’s quaint character.

2. Windermere High School Isn't Located in the Town of Windermere

It may surprise people who are not local to the area that Windermere High School is located outside the town limits, in unincorporated Windermere, about 6 miles from downtown. In fact, prior to the current high school opening, residents of Windermere originally attended West Orange High School, which is actually located in Winter Garden. In 2017, the current Windermere High School opened to relieve overcrowding at the West Orange High School. Even today, residents of downtown Windermere are zoned for Olympia High School, located east of Windermere.

3. The Windermere Post Office disappeared for a decade

Between 1891 and 1900, there was no Windermere post office or postmaster, and residents picked up their mail from nearby Gotha. The Windermere Post Office is known to have had at least 9 buildings serve as the town's post office over the years. The current Windermere post office opened in 1993 and sits on the east side of town, off Conroy Windermere Road.

4. Town Hall literally rolled down the road to its current site in 1938​

Originally, the Women's Club Building (known now as the town hall building) was located at Fernwood Park, at Seventh Avenue & Butler Street. Using logs as rollers, the building was pulled by truck to the current location and became known as the Community Club. It would not become Town Hall until 1945, when it was given to the town. The Windermere Town Hall was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1994 and remains the centerpiece of downtown on Main Street.

5. The police force started as a tiny two‑person team

It wasn't until the late 1960s that the Windermere police force had a second policeman join. In fact, in the early 1960s, there was no office; there was only a radio in the marshal's car. Today, the force has nine patrol officers, the Chief of Police, the Deputy Chief, Patrol Supervisors, and staff members. The current Windermere Police Department building, which opened alongside the Town of Windermere in 2022, is located on Main Street.

6. Luxury Communities in Windermere

Many people ask, Is Isleworth part of the town of Windermere? The Town of Windermere attempted to annex both Isleworth and Butler Bay in 2007. Butler Bay voted 90%+ to join the town, while the better-known Isleworth remained part of unincorporated Windermere. The Town of Windermere ended up with prime lakefront real estate, including some of its highest-value lakefront territory, without ever getting the more famous Isleworth name.

7. One of Orange County’s Oldest Towns Is Still One of Its Smallest

Windermere was already established long before the Disney-driven growth of Central Florida, yet today it’s known worldwide as home to celebrities and billionaires. Despite all that recognition, the town itself still has only a few thousand residents, retaining its authentic lake-town laid-back lifestyle while being close to attractions, shopping, and dining.

Which Real Estate Agent Knows Windermere Best?

Jeffrey and Renee Funk, founders of The Funk Collection, have spent decades working within the Windermere market, guiding clients through everything from lakefront properties to legacy homes. As Windermere residents and advisors, their approach is rooted in customer-first, deep local knowledge, thoughtful strategy, and consistent results.

That experience is backed by:

• Over 25 years of experience in Central Florida real estate
• 500+ five-star reviews across Google and online platforms
• RealtyInOrlando.com, a local resource serving the area since 2007
• A track record of listings that reflect consistency, not one-off wins
• Local Downtown Windermere Office
• A hands-on approach to communication, negotiation, and complex transitions

Backed by eXp Luxury, their reach is as strong as their reputation, but the focus stays local, where it matters most.

Curious what a move in Windermere could look like? Start the conversation at 407-285-9672.

*Sources: Windermere Among The Lakes by Carl Patterson, Jr., Town of Windermere, and Census Data (2024)

Tags

• Windermere history (4)
• facts about windermere (1)